Coffee with Mother Nicole: Questions That Free Us
On fear, belonging, and the image of God in us all

Sometimes, the questions that keep us awake at night aren’t really about the event we’re planning, the work we’re doing, or the decisions we have to make. They’re about something deeper. Something we’ve learned to fear. Something we’re afraid might be revealed about us if things don’t go the way we hoped.
I discovered this recently as I prepared for my first Fall Festival at St. Paul’s.
I had arrived at my first call as a priest with my trademark energy, enthusiasm, and a big smile. For the first couple of weeks, I ran around meeting people, learning names, dreaming up ideas, and throwing myself into the work. I was exhausted, but it was the good kind of exhausted. I loved being there.
Until the exhaustion changed. I began to feel as though I was being buried under weights I couldn’t crawl out from under. At my first clergy conference, I found myself asking other Associate Rectors how they did it. How did they decide which formation classes to offer? How did they gather a youth group and create programs for everyone from four-year-olds to high school seniors? How did they manage all the details without drowning in them?
And then Fall Festival approached. I should have been excited. I love creating spaces where children and families can experience the joy of belonging to a church community. But the closer the festival came, the more I dreaded planning the games, decorations, food, and all the little details that make an event come together. I procrastinated. I second-guessed myself. I felt paralyzed by decisions that should have been manageable.
I couldn’t understand why until a memory surfaced.
I was twenty-two years old, barely two months out of university. I had moved three states away, was adjusting to my first real apartment and my first full-time job, and was going to seminary on the side. Somehow, someone had decided it was a good idea to put me in charge of all the children at a little Baptist church. Fall Festival would be fun, they told me. People would come set up games and run them in the fellowship hall. All I had to do was decorate the entire gym-sized space, buy the candy, and organize everything. It would be great.
The day before the festival, people came to set up their games. But when it was time to decorate, no one showed up to help me. So I climbed ladders and hung streamers. I blew up balloons. I worked my way through the enormous room, trying to make it festive, trying to get everything ready, trying to make the event a success. Alone. And then I found myself lying on the floor of my church office, sobbing, unable to breathe. I didn’t even know what a panic attack was until that night. I had been so young, so new to adulthood and ministry, and so determined to make everything work. I don’t know that I had the words for what was happening inside me. I only knew that I couldn’t keep going, and I didn’t know what else to do.
Twenty years later, as I stood on the threshold of another Fall Festival, I began to understand what my body had remembered even when my conscious mind had not. My twenty-two-year-old self was screaming inside me: You can’t do this alone. You’re going to fall apart again.
And so I was dragging my feet, avoiding decisions, and dreading an event I wanted to love. Somewhere beneath all the logistics were the questions I was afraid to ask aloud. What if they don’t like it? What if the kids don’t come? What if no one shows up to help me? This time, though, something changed. Once I began to recognize what was happening, I started making the calls. I sent the emails and texts. We needed more chili for the chili cook-off. Could anyone help with Trunk or Treat? Would people come help us set up? And the responses began to arrive. I can help. What time do you want me there? What can I do?
They came. They showed up. And when the weekend arrived, the parish hall filled with children in costumes, little tasting cups of chili, laughter, and the particular kind of joyful chaos that happens when a community gathers. The festival was a success, but that wasn’t the most important thing that happened. Somewhere in the middle of it all, my twenty-two-year-old self received an answer she had needed for a very long time. You don’t have to do this alone.
No one had ever told that young woman that success didn’t mean proving she could manage everything. No one had told her that transition could be hard even when you loved your work, or that asking for help wasn’t a failure of leadership. And no one had reminded her that even if she fell flat on her face, God wasn’t asking her to prove her worth in the first place.
This year, I got to experience something different. I got to ask for help and receive it. I got to watch people bring their gifts, their energy, and their care to something we were creating together. I got to discover that the work didn’t have to rest entirely on my shoulders for it to matter. And in some quiet way, I think that changed something in me. I can forget that there is a difference between wanting something to flourish and believing that its flourishing is mine alone to secure.
Which brings me to the questions Jesus leaves with us in this week’s Gospel. When the Pharisees and Herodians try to trap Jesus with a question about paying taxes to the emperor, he responds by asking them to look at a coin: Whose image does it bear? And then he leaves them with a deeper question: What belongs to God? If the coin bears Caesar’s image, what bears the image of God? We do.
Before our accomplishments or our failures, before anyone decides whether we have done enough, before we know whether our plans will succeed, we bear the image of God. Our worth is not something we earn by getting everything right. It is a gift rooted in the love that created us.
Perhaps this is what I needed to remember as I prepared for Fall Festival. Perhaps it is what my younger self needed to hear on that office floor, too.
The world gives us so many ways to measure ourselves. Ministry success. Professional achievement. The approval of others. The number of people who show up. The plans that work and the ones that fall apart. But none of those things gets the final word about who we are.
So pour yourself a cup of coffee, settle in, and join me as I reflect on the questions that trap us, the stories our bodies remember, and the freedom of remembering whose image we bear.
Sermon
October 18, 2026
Twenty-First Sunday after Pentecost | Proper 24
St. Paul’s NewnanMatthew 22:15-22
Watch
Read
When we are children, one of the very first things we learn to do is ask questions. If you spend any time around toddlers, you will very quickly tire of the word “why?” We are curious by nature. Asking questions is how we learn about the world, about one another, and about ourselves.
And this is one of the reasons it matters so much that we include our youngest members in the life of our church and in our worship. Children and young people aren’t simply the future of the church. They are part of the church right now. Their curiosity, their questions, and their hunger to learn can remind the rest of us what it means to approach God with open hearts and open minds. Sometimes, they ask the questions we’ve forgotten to ask. Sometimes, they help us see something we’ve stopped noticing.
Today, as we celebrate our first Youth Sunday, we’re making a little more room for that truth. We are not just inviting young people to participate in what the church is already doing. We are recognizing that their presence matters, that their voices belong here, and that we have something to learn from one another as we grow in faith together.
As we grow older, though, questions can become something more than a way of learning. They can become a way of testing one another, drawing lines, and deciding who belongs and who doesn’t.
Some questions invite us to become more curious; others leave us feeling as though we have something to prove. And some of the most important questions invite us to look beneath the answers we’ve been given and ask whether they are telling us the whole truth.
In the Gospels, Jesus is constantly asking questions. And often, his questions don’t give people the answers they came looking for. Instead, they change the conversation completely. That’s what happens in today’s passage from Matthew. The Pharisees and the Herodians come to Jesus with a question designed to trap him: “Is it lawful to pay taxes to the emperor, or not?” They want to force him into a position they can use against him. But Jesus responds with a question of his own, one that takes the conversation somewhere they didn’t expect.
And as we listen to this encounter, I want us to pay attention not only to the question Jesus asks, but to the questions he leaves with us. Because there are questions that trap us in the judgments of the world, and then there are questions that help set us free. “Is it lawful to pay taxes?” sounds like a straightforward question, but it’s not. If Jesus says yes, he risks alienating people who resent Roman occupation and its demands. If he says no, he risks being accused of defying Roman authority. They are hoping to catch Jesus out. But he doesn’t accept the question on their terms.
Instead, Jesus asks them to show him a coin. “Whose head is this, and whose title?” he asks.
He doesn’t begin with a lecture about the relationship between religion and government. He asks them to look at something they are holding in their hands: a coin. It’s a denarius, the Roman coin used to pay taxes.
Imagine the scene for a moment. Someone comes forward holding a simple coin, a small piece of metal worn smooth from passing through countless hands. On one side is the image of the emperor, surrounded by an inscription declaring his title and authority. That tiny piece of metal represents far more than meets the eye.
Roman coins were made by taking a blank piece of silver and placing it between two heavy steel engraving dies. A worker struck it with a hammer, forcing the metal into the shape of Caesar’s profile and crown. His likeness was impressed into the coin so that his image and inscription could travel throughout the empire. For many people, that was the only image of their leader they would ever see.
The emperor’s image reminded people that they belonged to a system of power, exchange, and obligation. The coin carried his authority into ordinary life.
“Whose head is this?” Jesus asks. “The emperor’s,” they answer.
“Give therefore to the emperor the things that are the emperor’s, and to God the things that are God’s.”
That’s it. That’s all Jesus says. But his response leaves another question unanswered, one Jesus doesn’t answer for them: What belongs to God?
Now, this passage has often been used to talk about our obligations to the government, the taxes we pay, or what we give to the church. And those are certainly questions worth considering. But I wonder if we sometimes move too quickly to the practical question of what we owe and miss the deeper question Jesus is placing before us.
If the emperor’s image marks the coin as belonging to the emperor, then what bears the image of God? What belongs to God?
We do.
In the beginning, God creates humanity in the divine image. From the dust of the earth, God forms the human creature and breathes into it the breath of life. The coin bears Caesar’s image by force. But we bear God’s image through love, creation, and giving the breath of life. The Greek word for image here is the word from which we get our word icon. In the Christian tradition, icons aren’t simply pretty pictures to look at. They invite us to look through the image toward the holy reality it reveals, drawing our attention beyond themselves toward the presence of God.
What if we understood our own lives in something like this way? What if bearing the image of God isn’t simply a statement about what we are, but an invitation to consider what our lives might reveal?
We can become people through whom something of God’s character becomes visible: in the way we love, in the way we offer mercy, in the way we make room for another person, and in the way we care for those who are vulnerable.
An icon doesn’t draw attention to itself. It points beyond itself.
And this is part of our calling as human beings: not to spend our lives proving how valuable we are, but to live in such a way that the love of God becomes a little more visible in the world.
The coin bears an image and an inscription. It tells a story about who issued it, what it is worth, and where it belongs. We carry stories like that, too. Over time, other voices begin to tell us what we are worth, what makes us valuable, and what kind of people we are supposed to be.
So Jesus’ implied question turns toward us now: What has come to define you? What has the power to tell you who you are?
We all know how easy it is to let other things answer that question for us: our accomplishments, our failures, the approval of others, the groups we belong to, and the values we hold. Even our political identities can become so bound up with our sense of self that a disagreement feels like a rejection of who we are.
I know something about this myself. Over the past few weeks, I’ve caught myself measuring my worth as a priest by whether the work I’m doing succeeds, by the number of youth present, by whether people respond well, by whether I can make people happy. I had begun to confuse the success of the work with the worth of the person doing it. And those are not the same thing.
I had to take some extra time away from the office last week and really talk with my spiritual director and therapist about some deep work I need to keep doing about my own worth. We can become so invested in the things that tell us who we are that we forget the truth that came before all of them. Before our accomplishments or our failures, before our political convictions or our cultural identities, before anyone decided whether we belonged, we were created in the image of God.
And that brings us back to the question Jesus leaves unanswered: What belongs to God? If we bear God’s image, then the answer reaches far beyond the coins in our pockets or the portion of our income we give to the church. It reaches into the way we see every human being we encounter.
The person who votes differently from us bears God’s image. The person whose convictions trouble us, whose experiences are unfamiliar to us, whose life looks nothing like ours bears God’s image. The person we find difficult to love, the person we are tempted to dismiss, the person whose belonging we question—they bear God’s image, too.
This doesn’t mean our differences don’t matter, that every belief is equally true, or that we should remain silent in the face of injustice. Recognizing God’s image in another person doesn’t require us to agree with them. It does require us to remember that there is more to them than the thing we disagree about.
And it asks something of us when the lines between our identities become the lines by which we decide who deserves our concern, whose suffering matters, or who we write off. We live in a world that continually asks us to declare our loyalties, sort ourselves into groups, and decide who is on our side. There is nothing inherently wrong with belonging to a community. But no nation, political party, or cultural identity can contain the fullness of who we are. None can take the place of the God whose image we bear. And none gives us permission to forget whose image our neighbors bear.
Jesus is standing in a world where the emperor’s image is stamped on the currency and his authority reaches into ordinary life. The coin makes Caesar’s power visible. But Jesus reminds his listeners that Caesar is not the only claim upon their lives. There are things that belong to the emperor, and there are things that belong to God.
If we are made in God’s image, then our deepest identity and our ultimate allegiance cannot be settled by the powers of this world. We belong to God. And so does our neighbor.
I think this changes how we understand our life together as a church, too. We can become so focused on what it will take to sustain our ministries, whether there will be enough pledges, whether we can afford to do the things we hope to do, that fear begins to shape our imagination.
These are real responsibilities, and we must take them seriously. But our purpose is not simply to keep an institution going. It is to participate in God’s work in the world, to become a community in which people are loved, welcomed, formed, and sent to love and serve others.
When we remember that everything begins with a gift—our lives, our breath, our gifts, our capacity to love and serve—we can begin to respond to uncertainty with something other than fear.
Generosity becomes a response to what we have received, rather than a way to prove our faithfulness. And the way we treat one another becomes a reflection of the grace we ourselves have been given.
So let’s return to that little coin. Jesus holds it up and asks a question. His opponents came looking for an answer that would trap him, but Jesus leaves them with questions that reach far beyond the coin.
Whose image is this? And what belongs to God?
We have spent some time with questions of our own today. Who gets to claim your allegiance? Whose image do you bear? What has come to define you?
And now, one final question: What changes when we remember?
What changes when we remember that our worth is not something we have to establish? That our identity is not exhausted by the groups we belong to or the convictions we hold? What changes when we remember that the person across the aisle, or across the boundaries of culture and experience, bears the image of God just as we do? What about the person in the pews across from u who rubs us the wrong way?
Perhaps we begin to listen differently. We become slower to dismiss and quicker to recognize another person’s dignity.
We learn to hold our convictions without making them the measure of another person’s humanity. We become more willing to ask questions that open a conversation rather than questions designed to trap someone in the wrong answer.
So this week, when we find ourselves tempted to reduce someone to a single belief or a difference or opinion you cannot understand, I invite us to pause and ask ourselves a different question: Whose image do they bear?
And when the familiar voices of fear and doubt begin telling you who you are, remember that you, too, bear an image you did not earn. You are not the sum of your accomplishments or your failures. You are a human being, formed from the earth and alive with the breath of God.
The world keeps asking us to prove who we are. Jesus asks us to remember whose we are.
And when we remember, we begin to see ourselves differently. We begin to see one another differently. And we may begin to live differently, too.
Amen.
A Contemplative Moment: You Were Never Meant to Prove Your Worth
Take a moment before you move on with your day. Let your shoulders soften. Unclench your jaw. Take a slow, gentle breath.
Think about something in your life right now that feels heavy. Perhaps it’s a responsibility you carry, a relationship that feels uncertain, a decision you’re afraid to make, or a hope you’re not sure will come to fruition.
Now, listen for the questions that arise.
What if they don’t like it? What if I fail? What if no one shows up?
Don’t try to answer those questions just yet. Instead, become curious about them. What are they asking you to prove? What are they afraid might happen if you cannot make everything work, if someone is disappointed, or if you need help?
Sometimes, our fears belong partly to the present and partly to an older story. A younger version of ourselves may still be bracing for a disappointment we have long since survived. We may still be trying to earn the approval, security, or belonging we once believed depended on getting everything right.
If that feels familiar, see whether you can offer that younger self a little tenderness. You don’t have to solve the whole story today. You don’t have to make the fear disappear.
Simply remember this: Before you accomplished anything, before you disappointed anyone, before you knew what you were capable of or where you might fall short, you bore the image of God.
Your worth was never waiting on the other side of a successful endeavor. And you were never meant to carry everything alone.
Perhaps the question for today isn’t What if I fail? but What might become possible if I no longer had to prove that I am worthy?
What might you ask for? What might you risk? Where might you allow someone else to help carry the weight?
Rest here for a moment, in the knowledge that you are held by a love that does not depend on your performance.
You are made in the image of God. You belong to God. And that is true on the days when everything comes together beautifully, and on the days when you find yourself back on the office floor, wondering how you will manage it all. May you have the courage to ask for help, the grace to receive it, and the freedom to remember that you do not have to earn the love that has been yours all along.



Comments