Coffee with Mother Nicole: What We Bury When We’re Afraid
Finding the Freedom of a Life Rooted in Grace

Sometimes I wonder how much of our lives we organize around the possibility of getting something wrong. We hold back. We play it safe. We hesitate to say what needs to be said, take a risk, or step into something unfamiliar. And often, we have perfectly reasonable explanations for why. We tell ourselves we’re being careful, responsible, or simply waiting for the right time.
But what if, sometimes, what we’re really doing is protecting ourselves from the possibility of failure?
I’ve been sitting with that question this week, particularly as I’ve thought about the relationship between fear, love, and the way we imagine God. Because the things we believe about God have a way of shaping not only what we believe, but how freely we’re able to live.
As a friend and I reflected on this week’s Gospel reading, we found ourselves talking about how much our own early images of God had been shaped by the modern, Western end-times teaching we grew up around. Both of us recognized how those teachings had formed a faith rooted in fear for us. The expectation of Christ’s return, the warnings about judgment, the urgency of being ready, the possibility of being left behind. So much of our early understanding of faith was filtered through the question of whether we were prepared enough, faithful enough, or getting it right.
And it’s worth remembering that the particular Rapture-centered end-times framework so familiar in parts of Western Christianity is actually a relatively recent development, emerging in the 19th century. It’s easy, with all the ways these teachings have seeped into popular culture over the last half a century, to read Matthew’s final chapters through that lens and assume it’s how Christians have always understood them. But that framework is not the only way, or even the way the Church approached these passages for the first 1,800 years!
This was the lens through which I approached this week’s Gospel reading, Jesus’ parable of the talents. I wanted to spend some time with the detail that I think is easy to overlook: the third servant tells us plainly why he buried the talent. He was afraid.
After the sermon, several people came up to me and said some version of the same thing: “I’ve always wondered why the master was so harsh with that third servant. He didn’t really seem to do anything wrong. He just buried the money.”
And I think that’s exactly why paying attention to his fear matters. It changes the questions we ask of the story. Rather than simply asking why the servant didn’t do more, we begin to wonder what he believed about the master, how that belief shaped his response, and what his fear ultimately kept him from experiencing.
For me, that shift is important. Not because it means judgment doesn’t matter, or that how we live our lives is inconsequential. But because we cannot understand the demands of faithfulness apart from the grace that comes first.
What might our lives look like if we weren’t quite so afraid of getting it wrong? What might we risk, what might we offer, and what might become possible if we trusted that we were already held in God’s love?
What We Bury When We’re Afraid
Proper 28, Year A
25th Sunday After Pentecost
November 15, 2026
St. Paul’s Newnan
Watch
Read
As we near the end of Ordinary Time, this long season after Pentecost, we complete our walk through the Gospel of Matthew we’ve been immersed in all year. We are spending these last few weeks in chapters 24 and 25.
These are the final teachings we hear from Jesus before he turns toward Jerusalem, his arrest, and ultimately his death. They are his last extended words to his disciples before everything changes.
And they are not particularly easy words. They speak of judgment, separation, and weeping and gnashing of teeth. Again and again, Jesus tells stories that seem to end with someone on the outside, someone who didn’t measure up.
And if I’m honest, these are passages I’m tempted to hurry through. Especially now, as we’re standing on the threshold of Advent. We’re about to enter a season filled with images of expectation, longing, and the promise of God’s coming among us. But before we get there, Matthew gives us these unsettling stories of judgment.
Last week, we stood with ten bridesmaids waiting in the dark for a wedding banquet to begin. Father Winston reminded us that the bridegroom may be delayed, but he is coming. And we talked about what it means to be prepared and to remain faithful. Today, the story shifts from waiting to acting. We move from oil lamps in the night to a household in broad daylight, where a master hands over an astonishing amount of wealth to his servants and sets off on a journey.
These passages carry their own complicated history. For many of us, they have cultivated fear: fear of not being ready and of getting it wrong when the master returns. If you—like me— grew up anywhere near modern end-times teaching, you know how these chapters in Matthew are often preached.
The bridegroom is coming. The master is returning. The clock is ticking. And the underlying message is often a subtle—or not-so-subtle—warning: Don’t get caught unprepared. Don’t be left behind.
And when God’s judgment is framed primarily as the threat of being caught off guard, it does something to our faith. It can turn God into a cosmic examiner, clipboard in hand, waiting for us to slip up. We sit around wondering: Am I ready? Have I done enough? We can end up with a faith organized around fear rather than love.
But it’s important to remember that Jesus is speaking here within the long tradition of Israel’s prophets. The prophets repeatedly warned God’s people that when they turned away from the ways of God—when they pursued power, placed their trust in wealth and security, and neglected justice and mercy—the consequences were real.
The prophets warnings weren’t simply about some distant, otherworldly punishment. They were about the destruction that comes when a people lose their way and organize their lives around something other than God’s kingdom. And we see throughout the Jewish scriptures that Israel faced those real-world consequences of destruction and exile in their own time.
Likewise, Matthew places these final teachings directly after Jesus’ warnings about the coming upheaval in Jerusalem and the Temple’s impending destruction. The temple was, indeed, destroyed by Rome less than 40 years later, in 70 AD. These warnings, then, speak to the faithfulness of God’s people and the very real consequences of the paths we choose.
And yet, throughout that same prophetic tradition, we also hear something else. Again and again, God’s people are reminded that they belong to a God who has already called them, already made a covenant with them, already given them a place and a purpose. God’s invitation comes before their response. God’s generosity precedes their faithfulness.
And I think all of this context matters as we approach this parable. Because before we get to what the servants do with what they’ve been given, we need to notice that something has already been given. The master entrusts his property to them before they have done anything to prove themselves. The story begins not with a demand, but with an act of trust.
Perhaps we need to hold those two things together: the seriousness of how we live— and the generosity of what has first been entrusted to us. These parables then read not about needing to earn our place in God’s household. They become about we do with the life we’ve already been given. Before we talk about God’s judgment, I think we have to understand God’s grace.
Then, we can move from not simply, Are you ready for the master to return? But something closer to the heart of how we live right now: What does fear do to our capacity to participate in the life God has entrusted to us?
In today’s parable, a wealthy landowner is preparing to leave on a journey. Before he goes, he entrusts his property to three servants. A talent, by the way, is not a small coin or a personal gift. It is a means of measuring the weight of precious metals. One biblical talent equaled roughly 16 to 20 years of wages for a common laborer. In modern terms, based on average US worker pay, that translates to roughly $600,000 to $1.2 million for a single talent. In other words, even the servant who received one talent was entrusted with an extraordinary share in the master’s household.
The first two servants put what they’ve been given to work and double it. The third, however, takes this enormous share of the master’s money, digs a hole, and buries it. After a long time, the master returns and settles accounts with them. The first two are welcomed and invited to share in their master’s joy.
But the third servant comes forward with the original talent, explains that he was afraid, and gives it back. What follows is a harsh response from the master, ending with the servant cast into the outer darkness, where there is weeping and gnashing of teeth. It’s an unsettling story. And perhaps especially so because the servant doesn’t lose what he’s been given. He doesn’t squander it. He doesn’t steal it. He simply buries it.
What reason does the servant who does nothing give for his inaction? It’s not because he lacks ability or because he wasn’t given enough. He tells us exactly why: “I was afraid.” And then he tells the master something even more revealing: “I knew that you were a harsh man.”
Notice that before he ever buries the talent, he has already decided who the master is. His understanding of the master shapes everything that follows. He sees someone harsh and demanding. So he responds accordingly. He protects himself and minimizes risk.
And I think there’s something deeply recognizable here. When we believe that failure will bring disappointment, we begin to organize our lives around avoiding it. If you’re a parent, you know what I mean. Your young child will probably tell you any wild story about what else colored on the wall or broke that trinket, than admit fault and risk punishment. As we grow, we don’t stop doing this either.
Fear can make us become preoccupied with protecting ourselves. We can hold back and become so concerned with getting it right that we lose the freedom to actually live.
And this can happen in our spiritual lives, too. When faith becomes primarily about avoiding God’s displeasure or earning our way into the Kingdom, we spend an extraordinary amount of energy monitoring ourselves. Our attention turns inward, toward keeping our spiritual ledgers clean. And somewhere along the way, we can lose sight of God’s grace.
But faith was never meant to be simply an exercise in self-preservation or fast pass to heaven. It is an invitation into relationship, into love, and into the work of God’s kingdom. And that kind of life requires us to be willing to step beyond what is safe and predictable.
There is something worth noticing in the contrast between the servants. The first two take they’ve been given and put it into circulation. And when the master returns, they are welcomed into his joy. They are given more abundance. The third servant, on the other hand, spends the entire time protecting what he has been given. He approaches the relationship as though it were nothing more than a transaction, a matter of avoiding loss and settling accounts.
There is a tragic irony here. The servant is so convinced that the master is harsh, so certain that the safest thing to do is nothing, that he never gets to experience the master’s joy.
I wonder how often fear works this way in our own lives. How often do the things we believe about God, ourselves, or about the world shape the way we show up in it? When we imagine God primarily as someone waiting to catch us getting something wrong, we approach faith defensively. We bury things that were meant to be lived, shared, and offered.
And like the third servant, the tragedy isn’t simply that we risk losing something. It’s that we risk missing out on the life that was possible all along.
When we talk about grace and judgment, people sometimes assume that emphasizing one must weaken the other. But I think biblical grace and biblical judgment actually depend on one another. Judgment is proof that love is real.
Think about it this way: if a parent never steps in when one child harms another, that isn’t grace. It’s indifference to the suffering of the hurt child. Love doesn’t simply overlook harm. Love cares enough to name what is destructive and to insist that it cannot have the final word in our lives. God’s judgment means that evil, oppression, injustice, and apathy do not simply get a pass.
While grace welcomes us into God’s love, judgment reminds us that how we live, how we treat one another, and what we do with what has been entrusted to us matters. So judgment isn’t about whether we’ve managed to earn God’s love. It is about the seriousness of what we are doing with the grace and life given to us.
And that brings us back to what the third servant has to teach us. What does it look like to bury what has been entrusted to us?
We bury our voices when we have something important to say but remain silent because we’re afraid of how someone might respond. We’d rather just keep the status quo. We can bury our generosity when we hold tightly to what we have because we’re afraid there won’t be enough. Sometimes we bury our capacity to love. We hold back from relationships, from reconciliation, from showing up for someone who needs us, because love always involves some vulnerability and a lot of time. We cannot control how what we do will be received or guarantee that it won’t cost us something.
And churches can do this, too. We can become so concerned with protecting what we have built, preserving what is familiar, and avoiding the possibility of failure that we stop taking the kinds of risks that allow a community to grow and flourish.The opposite of burying our talents isn’t becoming wildly successful. It’s becoming willing to join in God’s work. We can only step out in faith with what’s been entrusted with us and trust the Spirit to multiply it.
So, as we listen to this parable, can we set aside the fear of whether we’ve managed to get everything right and ask instead: What have I buried because I was afraid? What part of my life have I held back? And what might become possible if fear were no longer making those decisions for me?
The First Letter of John speaks directly to this tension between love and fear: “Love has been perfected among us in this: that we may have boldness on the day of judgment, because as he is, so are we in this world. There is no fear in love, but perfect love casts out fear; for fear has to do with punishment, and whoever fears has not reached perfection in love.”
These verses speaking about this particular kind of fear: the fear of punishment. And John offers us a different way. Love gives us a different place from which to live. It is remembering that as Christ is, so we are in this world. His life, death, and resurrection have defeated death, the grave, and fear once and for all. And we are invited into his life.
When we begin to trust that we are already held in God’s love, we no longer have to organize our lives around protecting ourselves from every possible failure. We can begin to live with greater freedom, greater generosity, and greater courage.
When we hold grace and judgment together, obedience stops being an anxious attempt to avoid punishment. We can live faithfully because we trust the God whose love has already come to meet us. And that love calls us into a life that reflects it. I think that’s a good place for us to stand as we approach Advent in a couple of weeks.
We are about to tell again the story of a God who doesn’t hold back. A God who enters into the vulnerability of human life, who comes among us not in power and protection but in the fragile form of a human child. A God who risks drawing near.
And following that God means learning to live with something of that same open-handedness. It means willing to offer what we have, willing to love with his self-sacrificing love.
Because the invitation of this parable is not simply to make it safely to the end of the journey, having managed not to lose what we’ve been given.
It is to live the life we’ve been entrusted with—to risk joining in the work of the Master’s household. And to discover that the joy of the master isn’t simply something waiting for us at the end. It is something we can begin to enter into right now.
Amen.
Listening with you, Nicole
A contemplative moment to carry with you this week...
I wonder if it’s worth taking a little time to notice where fear might be shaping your life. Not the obvious fears necessarily, but the quieter ones: The things you hold back. The conversations you avoid. The generosity you hesitate to offer. The parts of yourself you keep tucked away because you’re not quite sure what might happen if you let them come into the light.
As you notice those places, I invite you to consider what you believe about God in those moments.
Do you imagine a God who is waiting for you to get something wrong? Or can you begin to trust the God whose generosity has already made room for you, whose love precedes anything you could ever do to earn it?
Take a breath. Let yourself rest for a moment in the knowledge that you are already held in God’s love.
And then, ask: What is one small way I might live a little more freely, a little more generously, a little more courageously this week? Not because I have something to prove, but because I have already been given so much.
May we find the courage to live the lives we’ve been entrusted with, and the freedom to discover the joy that has been waiting for us all along.



Comments